Social Networking Project Overview
Rationale: This assignment fulfills important
requirements for both the Information Literacy and Quantitative
Reasoning Learning Goal.
- You will demonstrate the ability to find articles on a topic,
form a thesis and relate the articles you find to that thesis.
- By choosing 2 articles from inside a database, you demonstrate the ability
to navigate a database to find information.
- By choosing article that is scholarly, you evaluate a source as scholarly
and show you can draw information you need from the article.
- By locating numbers that support your thesis and creating a
graph, you show that you can present numerical data in a
meaningful format, and that you can use Excel to create a well
formed graph.
- Your one page discussion on your numerical data proves you can draw inferences
from numerical data and properly use inline citations.
- Your annotation of sources proves that you can properly cite, evaluate sources
and draw inferences from your research.
Overview: You will research one narrow issue of a social networking
or technology ethical topic and then produce the following documents on that
topic:
- A thesis statement with a bibliography of five sources, 2 of which must
come from a database, 1 which must be scholarly, plus 2 other sources. Your
thesis statement will be a hypothesis about what research suggests on a particular
topic.
- An annotated bibliography of your sources, using a special 4 part format
designed for this project.
- A one page numerical data presentation: Numerical data Excel graph and discussion
using inline citations. You will find one set of numerical data supporting
an argument for your thesis, and then graph that data using Excel and write
a discussion explaining how the data was collected, what it represents and
how it supports your argument.
- Note: You will never write the complete the full research
paper. In this class, you are only doing preparation steps for writing a final
paper.
This will be broken into separate assignments:
Possible topics: Please choose a topic relating to a
ethical dilemma that has arisen due to technology changes. Click
here for a list of possible topics.
Deliverable #1: Write the thesis statement and bibliography of five sources:
- Research databases to find five sources related to your topic. Click
here for database suggestions.
- Find at least 2 sources from a database, 1 scholarly (peer reviewed
or law review) article, and 2 other sources.
- Write a thesis in the form of: research suggests that (hypothesis) because (list 1, 2, 3 supporting points).
- Example: While there were active discontents in each North African nation
involved in the Arab Spring, the availability of Social Networking was
a requirement for turning that discontent into a rapid spread of revolution
throughout North Africa. Research suggests social
networking played a vital role because it was available under the governments radar,
it provided a means for political organizers
to gain support for their message, and because political organizers would not have been able
to coordinate events quickly without it.
- The hypothesis should form
a position on an issue, not describe an issue:
- For example, the hypothesis that "cyberbullying is
bad" is a description while the hypothesis "stopping cyberbullying is
the responsibility of schools" is a position.
- Include at least 2 supporting points.
- Write a bibliography. It can be in MLA or APA format (or ask me if
you want to use a different format) but all citations must use the same style
- Use the Purdue
Owl MLA Guide or Purdue
Owl APA Guide
- Please include the database name in the citation
- Format with a hanging indent so the beginning
sticks out to the left
- Alphabetize the bibliography by the first word in the citation.
- Many databases have citation tools attached or have the citation at
the end. Be sure to choose the correct format (APA or MLA).
- You may find this powerpoint
helfpul.
- For web sites that are not found in databases: place the root web site
name after the citation. For example, put www.adelphi.edu/~pe16132 at
the end of a citation on my site.
- Citation Makers: Don't get caught by relying too heavily on a citation
maker. A common issue with citation makers is not including both the
title and journal for a journal article. It also commonly does not include
the article title, site and publisher of a web site citation. For database
articles, you will often have to add the database name yourself.
Deliverable #2: Update your Bibliography to add annotations of your 5 sources:
(broken into 2 assignments (first
and finish) so that you
can get feedback on one annotation before doing all 5)
- Your goal is to communicate to the reader how to find the source, the credibility
of the source, and what you would plan to use from the source if you were
writing a paper to support your thesis.
- Start the Annotated Bibliography with your thesis statement.
- Each annotation will include these 4 parts:
- Citation: citation of the source
- choose one format for the entire annotated bibliography (either APA
or MLA preferred but you can choose another and tell me which you are
using.)
- Summary: Write a brief summary of the material covered by the article.
- Include the main point of the article and a high level view of the
topics covered.
- Credentials Analysis: Write about the credibility of the source,
including all the items below:
- Credentials of author or source
- Qualifications as authority - Find this by researching the author
or organization on the internet. Find out who they work for and
what their field of study or expertise is. ( Be sure to search using
the full name of the author and their affiliation to get the right
person.)
- Quality of other articles published
- Publisher - who is the publisher and also who owns the publisher
- Bias - interest of publisher or author. Mention these signs of bias:
- Is it in a publication or site meant to sell or convince of a
certain viewpoint?
- Does it use persuasive language?
- Are both sides of a viewpoint included?
- Is it missing significant facts or viewpoints from other articles
you found.
- Validity of numerical statistics in article
- Are any numerical facts included?
- Do numerical facts include a citation of the study they came from
so you can verify the facts?
- Are the statistics based upon a study with a large sample size?
- Are there conflicting stats on the internet or in other articles?
If so, indicate which stats seem to you to be more correct and why.
- Verifiable
- can you follow the citations?
- are the sources of the citations biased?
- Is it peer reviewed, referreed or a legal review? (Find out whether
the journal is peer reviewed. Ulrich's
Web lists whether a journal is peer reviewed or refereed. Also,
some databases have a peer-reviewed filter that can prove the journal
is peer reviewed. )
- Category
- You may find this powerpoint
helpful.
- What I might use: Explain how the source will fit into your essay
and how it relates to your thesis. Include facts.
- Mention facts or discussions you would plan to use from the source
if you were going to write your paper.
- Describe which section of your paper this source would support
or refute.
- For example: This article provides a counter-argument to facebook
being only slightly useful to the Arab Spring.
- This section must relate directly to the thesis. It should not include
any information that is not directly related to your thesis.
- You do not need to include in-text citations because the source is clear,
but if you copy text use quotes.
Deliverable #3: Write
the numerical data presentation:
- Find numerical data in your research that supports or refutes your argument.
- Create one or two graphs in Excel to convey the numerical data in a clear
manner.
- Even if your data was in a graph in your research, you need to recreate
the graph in Excel on your own.
- The graph also needs to be clearly marked so that the information is
visually accurate and easy to understand on its own, with a clear title,
and clear axis labels.
- The graph cannot be misleading, so a pie chart would need to be parts
of a whole, and a bar chart would need to start at 0 and have parallel
values and trend lines would need to have reasonable outer bound lines,
and all data points must accurately reflect the numbers.
- Write a discussion paper as a word document with these parts:
- Insert a picture of your Excel graph
- Write a one page discussion explaining how the graphed numbers support
your thesis.
- Use at least one inline (parenthetical citation) citation for each
paragraph that has any facts that rely upon the source. If you copy
text, be sure to use quotes.
- Describe the scope of the numbers including a description of the
sample set they came from. Mention the sample size as well.
- Discuss the graph itself and significant information it is presenting.
- Explain the inferences that support or refute your argument. Mention
at least one of your thesis arguments that is being supported.
- You do not need to write about any of your research that is not
found in the graph or to prove your entire thesis - this is all about
analyzing the numbers.
- Write this in third person (no "I" or "you")
and avoid "I believe".
- You do not need to explain how you found the numbers, but instead,
just cite the source.