It's difficult to
restrict access to the internet because it's necessary in
today's day and age.
"When
parents see a problem, it’ssometimes temptingto try to ban
children from using social media. But a ban is difficult
to enforce, given the reliance on the internet for
education." (Healy)
How do you ban something that
is used for education? Even though the internet is
necessary for education, social media isn't. But how do
you restrict access to social media when it's connected
via internet?
"It
may also be counter-productive. Most 14- to 17-year-oldsreportthat the
internet is very important to them, saying it improves
their wellbeing andrelationships." (Healy)
Would
it be more harmful to keep access to social media or
restrict access to social media? If people are
claiming that they believe that the internet (social
media) is important to them, wouldn't you be harming
them more by taking away something they believe to be
precious?
"Arecent reviewof
international research confirms that participation in
social media can increase teenagers’ feelings of
self-esteem, support, and fitting in with a group.
Children relate to each other through social media,
for good and for bad." (Healy)
It is true that social
media is a way for people to stay connected, People
could confide in other people anonymously, meaning
that they could share things about themselves
without actually exposing themselves. This allowed
people to share things about themselves that no one
else knows while also relieving a burden that they
carry if they don't share this "secret".
Most of the studies done on
cyberbullying and it's correlation to health related
issues are done in isolation.
"Arecent reviewof
international research confirms that participation
in social media can increase teenagers’ feelings of
self-esteem, support, and fitting in with a group.
Children relate to each other through social media,
for good and for bad." (Olweus)
Meaning that the
group that they're researching is more
concentrated than what it would be in the real
world. The author is arguing that the issues of
cyberbullying may be over exaggerated because the
sample that they are working with may be bias.
It
is unclear whether the causes of depression are due to
regular bullying or cyberbullying.
The victims of one or the
other both exhibit the same correlation to health
issues.
"This is because the
great majority of cyberbullied children and
youth are also bullied in traditional ways, as
documented above. How do we try to find out what
the "true" effects of cyberbullying are,
independent of possible effects of traditional
bullying?" (Olweus)
Since it's
unclear which of the two is the actual cause of health
problems, the highlighted cause will lead to a funneling of
resources. However, since you don't know which is the
actually cause this could be a waste of resources.
"Second, such a
picture is likely to result in an unfortunate shift in the
focus of anti-bullying work if digital bullying is seen as
the key bullying problem in the schools. This would
probably also result in funnelling a lot of resources in a
"wrong" direction while traditional bullying—which is
clearly the most prevalent and most serious problem—would
be correspondingly downgraded." (Olweus)
Sources
Olweus, Dan. “Cyberbullying:
An Overrated Phenomenon?”
European Journal ofDevelopmental Psychology, vol.
9, no. 5,
Sept. 2012, pp 520-538. EBSCOhost,
doi:10.1080/17405629.2012.682358.
Accessed 2
March 2019.
Healty,
Karyn. "Blocking kids
from social media won't solve the problem of cyberbullying." TheConversation.
13 October 2016. https://theconversation.com/blocking-kids-from-social-media-wont-solve-the-problem-of-cyberbullying-66280.
Accessed
20 February 2019.